When the Swing Marches On - Schaars

When the Swing Marches On - Schaars

Aliud  ACD BR 772

Stereo/Multichannel Hybrid


Marine Band of the Royal Netherlands Navy
Dutch Swing Collage Band
Major Peter Kleine Schaars

Marine Band of the Royal Netherlands Navy & Dutch Swing College Band: When the Swing Marches On. Joining forces, a spectacular LP was released in 1968 with the apt title: When The Swing Comes Marching In. Countless joint performances followed to sold out Dutch theatres and many requests have resulted in this new, unique recording, full of fresh swinging arrangements complemented by successes from the olden days.

Support this site by purchasing from these vendors using the links provided below.
As an Amazon Associate earns from qualifying purchases.


Add to your wish list | library


0 of 0 recommend this, would you recommend it?  yes | no

1. High Society
2. Perdido Street Blues
3. Anchors Aweigh
4. Dans Les Rues D'Antibes
5. Sensation Rag
6. My Inspiration
7. Stars And Stripes Forever
8. Little One
9. Copenhagen
10. Swanee
11. Royal Garden Blues
12. St. Louis Blues Fantasy
13. Original Dixieland One Step
14. High School Cadets
15. Basin Street Blues
16. South Rampart Street Parade
Reviews (1)

Review by John Miller - August 1, 2015

Jazz reached the height of its popularity in America during the Swing era, which originated in the dark days of the Depression in New Orleans. It continued to the victorious end of World War II, although the famous Big Band Sound suffered from the reduction of players being involved in military activities. Duke Ellington christened “Swing” with his 1932 hit record, “It Don’t Mean a Thing If It Ain’t Got That Swing” and this approved the "new" style.

Swing jazz is characterized by its strong rhythmic drive and an almost orchestral "question and answer" style between different sections of the ensemble. The band's rhythm section – piano, bass, drums and guitar – hold the swinging dance beat, while trumpets, trombones and woodwinds were mostly scored to play together, providing the emotional focus of the piece. On a larger scale, the fusion of the Marine Band of the Royal Netherlands Navy (MBRNN) with the Dutch Swing College Band (DSCB) on this present recording demonstrates that arrangers throughout the ages have exploited this 'question and answer' style to maximum affect. Joining these Dutch forces goes back to 1968, when the two issued an LP entitled "When the Swing Comes Marching In", which was an instant sell-out. Aliud have responded to the many requests for a repeat, and here is the new version, which has the significant benefit of high-definition sound.

The Dutch Swing College Band started out as an amateur-college combo on World War II's Liberation Day (May 5th,1945). Through the years it has grown into a world-famous jazz ensemble that has toured all five continents, to much acclaim. The 7 players of DSCB were (and are) a traditional Dixieland band, originally founded by their original band-leader and clarinettist/saxophonist Peter Schilperoort. Bob Kaper is now musical director and plays clarinet and alto saxophone, taking his group to many venues and towns in Europe, including Amsterdam's Concertgebouw Jazz Concerts.

Marine Band of the Royal Netherlands Navy is based in Rotterdam, and was also founded in 1945, as a continuation of the pre-war Regimental Band of the Royal Netherlands Navy, founded by King Willem III in 1864. Nowadays this ensemble is made up of 53 professional musicians of both sexes, who, combined with the artistic and creative abilities of their conductors, have substantially contributed to the development and appreciation of military music in the Netherlands; as they tour across the globe, they are pass this on to others.

The 16 tracks cover a range of classic swing from the usual range of DSCB's Dixieland repertoire, such as the opening Steel & Melrose 'High Society', Louis Armstrong's 'Perdido Street Blues' (with stunning clarinet and muted trumpet solos) and E.B. Edward's 'Sensation Rag'. Quieter items like Cole Porter's 'Little One' swing sensually and ooze smoothly along. Arrangers bring the Navy Band into each of these tracks with great skill and amusement, the Navy taking up themes from the DSCB and bringing them into the Navy's splendid symphonic depth and warmth, as provided by three euphoniums, five trombones, three tubas and five horns, not to mention fifteen clarinets, two bassoons, four saxophones, two each of oboes and flutes, piccolo and double bass. The Navy Band, of course, has some tracks of its own repertoire, such as Sousa's marches 'Stars and Stripes Forever' &' High School Cadets', and the arrangers soon make these swing and toss it over to be treated by DSCB's jazz trickery.

Another way of combining the two bands is to compose a piece especially for them, and precisely that has been done by MBRNN's conductor, Major Peter Kleine Schaars. Based on a melody by W.C. Handy, one of Dixieland's most famous song-writers, 'St. Louis Blues Fantasy' shuttles material between the bands and even produces a few bars of harmonic progressions which could grace some moderniser's music with aplomb.

This recording was made in the rehearsal room of the Navy Band in Rotterdam, which has a pretty rapid decay with a somewhat metallic caste. The Dutch Swing College Band is pretty close to the front, almost stretching between the main front speakers, with a bright and clear take on all their instruments in a slightly dry ambience. The Navy Band seems to be seated in an arc around and behind the DSCB's players, and when they enter with their warm and fullsome sound, it is quite thrilling, particularly in the deep bass region. To my ears, this switching between the two bands has been handled very well; I can easily imagine being in the large rehearsal room, and this is also true for the Stereo track.

A gift for those fans of Dutch Swing Music who are not too purist about a military band playing with a Dixie group. I found it very interesting sonically - if you have never heard Jazz and Military bands in DSD sound, here is your opportunity. There is also another task for the listener - tracking down various well-known tunes cleverly inserted into the arrangements without mention. Fun is, I think, the keyword for this disc, which provides excellent entertainment and sonic satisfaction. Great for parties!

Copyright © 2015 John Miller and


Sonics (Stereo):

Sonics (Multichannel):

stars stars stars
Comments (2)

Comment by Euell Neverno - August 25, 2015 (1 of 2)

Interesting that John Miller refers to Big Band Swing as jazz. I doubt most Americans would identify most Big Band music of the 1930's and 1940's as jazz, even Duke Ellington, and certainly not the Swing sound of Glen Miller, Tommy Dorsey, Harry James, Benny Goodman and many others. It was mostly the pop of the era. Stan Kenton, Don Ellis, Buddy Rich, Shorty Rogers and others in the 1950's and 1960's popularized Big Band Jazz licks, which are quite different from so-called Swing of the WWII era and prior decades. To be distinguished is Dixieland Jazz, which did originate in New Orleans, but which typically does not involve a "big" band.

Comment by Mark Werlin - August 25, 2015 (2 of 2)

From "Dark Passage" (Warner Bros. 1947). Bogart: “You must like swing.” Bacall: “Yes, legitimate swing.”