SearchsearchUseruser

Bruckner: 9 Symphonies - Karajan

Bruckner: 9 Symphonies - Karajan

Universal  4837137

Stereo

Classical - Orchestral


Bruckner: 9 Symphonies

Berliner Philharmoniker
Herbert von Karajan (conductor)

Add to your wish list | library

 

1 of 1 recommend this, would you recommend it?  yes | no

All
show
Recording
show
hide
Mixed recording
Comments (11)
show
hide

Comment by DYB - June 28, 2019 (1 of 11)

I guess the big question is did they do any kind of "cleaning" or "remastering" of Symphonies 1 - 3, or did they just upsample and leave it at that?

Comment by marc lubin - June 29, 2019 (2 of 11)

I was wondering the same thing. I already have the other symphonies, 4-9 on SACDs from Japan so I don't know if it's worth it to spring for this set as well. BTW, its selling for $40.75 at Presto Music in the UK which is quite a bit lower than other prices I've seen.

Comment by Contrapunctus - July 2, 2019 (3 of 11)

To all those who own this new edition already: does the booklet give any information about remastering/studio? - Symphonies 4-9 are also available now as 24/192 download, but without any additional information/booklet.

Comment by Gordon Lilley - July 4, 2019 (4 of 11)

there is some very positive and detailed comments under the Amazon UK listing.

Comment by marc lubin - July 4, 2019 (5 of 11)

Gordon, thanks for the reference to the review. I found it useful.

Comment by DYB - July 5, 2019 (6 of 11)

Definitely some interesting info at amazon.uk. To summarize: DG remastered 4-9 from original analog at 96/24 (why bother upsampling to 192???) But still unclear if anything was done (remixing of any kind) of 1-3. Or did they literally just take the 1980s discs and upsampled them to 192 (again, why so high?)

AND - I think there is still a question if these are the same masters as the ones Universal released on SACD in Japan. Those were remastered by Emil Berliner in 2017 and appear to have been remastered at 192/24.

So, we *appear* to have:

Symphonies 4-9:
1) Universal Japan SACDs (and downloads at e-Onkyo Japan) of 2017 remasters by Emil Berliner Studios at 192/24
2) DG remasters at 96/24 upconverted to 192/24 for blu-ray

Symphonies 1-3:
1) Upconverted from CD to 192/24 for blu-ray by DG; remixing/remastering status unclear.

Comment by Contrapunctus - July 6, 2019 (7 of 11)

DYB, I'm convinced that Emil Berliner Studios did NOT the remastering for symphonies 4-9. The EBS-remastering was exclusively for Universal Japans SHM-SACD (+ corresponding japanese HR-downloads). It's most likely, that another studio like MSM Munich or Polyhymnia did the remastering for Universals Blu-ray release. (Compare comments to Karl Böhm's Mozart Symphonies on Blu-ray and SHM-SACD for example.)

Comment by ubertrout - July 11, 2019 (8 of 11)

I'm not sure why people are assuming that (1) this is not the EBS remastering and (2) that' a 24/96 remastering upsampled to 24/192. The one Amazon UK review mentions both sampling rates but it doesn't seem from the tenor of the review that there's any inside information - I suspect the reviewer simply got confused.

Perhaps more to the point, if EBS just did a 24/192 transfer recently, why on earth would Universal pay for another one? I know we're eager to see the JSACDs as ne plus ultra, but it seems reasonable to assume it's the same transfer to me. Or is there other evidence?

Comment by Contrapunctus - July 12, 2019 (9 of 11)

Ubertrout, I've commented on this before several times, so I make it short:
1.) Universal and Universal Japan are totally independend companies.
2.) The remasterings that Universal Japan gathered via EBS are exclusively for Universal Japan.
3.) Universal is - so far - not able to use the Japanese (EBS) remasterings. That's weird, but true.
4.) In the end, it's a problem of license/copyright = legal questions.
5.) Consequently, Universal uses older remasterings from EBS (before 2008*) or they commission a new studio (like MSM Munich or Polyhymnia NL).

*) In 2008 EBS and Deutsche Grammophon/Universal got separated.

A very striking example for this absurd situation are Böhm's Mozart Symphonies/BPO on Blu-Ray and SACD: different remasterings from different studios. And most strange: the remastering work in both studios was done in the same year. Incredible!

Comment by Contrapunctus - July 14, 2019 (10 of 11)

According to amazon.co.uk-reviewer Huntley Haverstock this blu-ray-compilation has been remastered by MSM Studios/Munich.

Comment by Ramesh Nair - Yesterday 06:27 pm (11 of 11)

It's a shame HvK's circa 1968 recording of Bruckner 9, also with the BPO, has been orphaned. Universal Japan included the Te Deum and Wagner's Siegfried Idyll in their SACD set of B7-9. [ Both fabulous performances. I wonder if James Galway was the flute on the Wagner, for the flute sound has a breathy fulsomeness typical of that artist ]. Sad even they excluded the earlier performance.

I note that in the DG 'complete Carlos Kleiber' BRA, the Brahms 4 early digital recording was 'upsampled', while Tristan und Isolde, another digital recording, was presented as 'plain Jane' 16 bit. In my system the Brahms 4 sounded less glassy than the Tristan recording, though I can't say this was due to the remastering.