SearchsearchUseruser

Opera Suites for Nonet - Ensemble Minui

Opera Suites for Nonet - Ensemble Minui

Ars Produktion  ARS 38 290

Stereo/Multichannel Hybrid

Classical - Chamber


Strauss: Der Rosenkavalier
Puccini: Tosca
Dvorak: Rusalka
(all arranged by Stefan Potzmann)

Ensemble Minui

 

Add to your wish list | library

 

3 of 4 recommend this, would you recommend it?  yes | no

All
show
Reviews (1)
show
hide

Review by Adrian Quanjer - February 16, 2020

Less is More?

Some years ago, colleague Mark Werlin enthused about Mahler’s ninth symphony in a ‘reduced’ version for small ensemble Mahler: Symphony No. 9 - Gale calling it “a very enjoyable listening experience” … “presenting a very familiar work in an unfamiliar context, so that the music itself may be reconsidered and newly appreciated”. More recently I reviewed TRPTK’s recording of Beethoven’s second symphony in another reduced version, played ‘breathtakingly’ well by the nine members of the InterContinental Ensemble (published on the blog site of Native DSD). Here we have a ‘Nonet’, consisting of nine prominent members of the Kärntner Sinfonieorchester (Carinthian Symphony Orchestra), Klagenfurt, Austria, calling themselves Ensemble Minui (derived from Latin ‘making it smaller’), with an unusual programme borrowed from three well-known operas ‘to broaden the repertoire for Nonets’.

Music for nonets is, indeed, limited and, at least initially, mostly meant for ‘salon’ performances. Of late, more ambitious compositions have seen the light, but there clearly is room for more. The charm of such smaller chamber ensembles is that nine musicians, usually, though there is no hard and fast rule, composed of a mixture of strings and wind instruments, amongst which a contra-bass and a horn, are able to cover the entire range of an orchestra. Joolz Gale’s Ensemble Mini and the InterContinental Ensemble, though not quite in the same league, effectively demonstrate how ‘Less is More’ by successfully creating a whole ‘new' range of reduced orchestral repertoire, giving the listener a chance to better understand and follow the complexities of the score.

Stefan Potzmann, the clarinettist of Minui, had the brilliant idea to apply the principle of ‘Less is More’ to the opera, and notably by including ‘voice’ in the reductions. For his arrangements of excerpts taken from three popular operas -calling them Nonet Suites- he chose a very present-day, though possibly as old as humanity, common denominator: Powerful Women (please read the liner notes). In order of appearance: Strauss’ Marschallin, The Benevolent; Puccini’s Tosca, The Impulsive, and Dvorak’s Rusalka, The Naïve. The strength of these suites lies not only in the choice of the parts relating to some main events and the inclusion of the famous La Tosca and Rusalka’s Moon arias, but also, and more than anything else: The excellent quality of Potzmann’s arrangements.

As said above, the nine members of Ensemble Minui come from the same orchestra, with the obvious advantage of knowing one another inside out. This puts their overall performance in a much better focus than some ad hoc ensembles, getting together for the sake of making a recording, with short practicing time and limited recording sessions, are able to achieve. The result is as evident as it is a most revealing experience: After several rounds of intensive and analytical listening I couldn’t but admit that these musicians are in no way junior to any of their colleagues in the Big Orchestras.

No doubt greatly helped by the musical ears, the technical skills and the immense patience of the ARS recording engineers, Martin Rust and Manfred Schumacher, I was able to fully indulge in the selected opera arrangements, played with so much musical commitment and radiant finesse, even to the point -and perhaps strangely so- that I did not miss any of the singing parts! Cynical people might say that it allowed me to enjoy the score without being distracted by all too ambitious singing.

The sound has clearly been mastered for the many surround aficionados who enjoy being wholly part of the action, preferring to sit in between, rather than in front of the musicians. It certainly does give an additional boost to the soundstage and a large amount of extra thrill as well, but if such is not your take, I suggest to sit more upfront or lower the volume of the surround speakers.

First-rate sound, top arrangements, and perfect playing is one thing, but there is more that merits our genuine attention; something that is also close to my heart: A recording in high resolution is expensive, and for the many talented musicians and orchestral formations, having no fixed contract with the Big Labels, nor an invitation from a smaller, independent one, it is difficult to procure the necessary funds, if it weren’t for cultural and private initiative support programmes and, indeed, modern times obliging: Crowd Funding, to lend them a generous hand. We, lovers of music, produced and recorded in the highest attainable quality, should be immensely grateful for all those having made this fantastic release possible.

Mission accomplished ‘cum laude’.

Blangy-le-Château, Normandy, France.

Copyright © 2020 Adrian Quanjer and HRAudio.net

Performance:

Sonics (Multichannel):

stars stars
Comments (5)
show
hide

Comment by hiredfox - February 19, 2020 (1 of 5)

An interesting concept that catches the eye. "Highlights" recordings do not have much appeal for this listener but this one might be interesting. Any thoughts?

Comment by oxenholme - March 20, 2020 (2 of 5)

This one is more than "interesting". I think that it is superb. I love the sheer variety of music on Ars Produktion.

Comment by Adrian Quanjer - March 22, 2020 (3 of 5)

Hi Oxenholme, I don't know about you, but if we in France say 'not bad' it means 'good' and if it is very good some say 'not bad at all'. So, I take 'might be interesting' as a positive understatement. And you are right: 'superb' it is.

Comment by Mark Mitchell - April 30, 2020 (4 of 5)

Awesome recording and transcription.

Comment by hiredfox - May 6, 2020 (5 of 5)

I am all for innovation in music if it enhances or refines the musical experience for the listener. The role of the musician is after all to interpret and express in sound the sentiments and emotions they see hidden in the composers written score. Some do that better than others as all are aware which often separates the sublime from the ordinary. In this recording the musical intention seems confused and the effect on this listener was unsurprisingly utterly confusing. At times I wanted to scream out loud!

The three musical extracts lack any sort of context through the dislocation of the familiar story telling of the operas chosen for Ensemble Minui's treatment. Taken out of context the music becomes largely meaningless reduced to a collection of disjointed melodic sounds. One is bound to ask if the musicians wanted to be different for differences sake with perhaps a hint of arrogance tied in. If so it was a very risky strategy for commercial success and ARS have taken a huge gamble in recording and issuing this disc. Others may relish this off the wall approaches to music making but most certainly it is not for me.

I cannot recommend it to any serious collector, at best it is a frivolous extravagance.