A rare pairing: organ and piano, two entirely different ‘keyboard’ instruments. The keys are their only common feature. The organ is a wind instrument, while the piano is a percussion instrument. The organ has an offset mechanism; the piano is directly accessible. And what about their sheer power? This MDG release shows that both, like in earlier days, can successfully perform together. Practically, it would be beneficial to have a location where the organ console and the grand piano are on the same floor level.

The recording was made in the Hall of the CJD Christophoruschule in Rostock, Germany. The small size of its recently restored organ allowed a manageable equilibrium with the Bechstein grand in the same hall. Details are given in the booklet. With these prerequisites in place, the project, of which the execution was entrusted to Jan von Bush at the organ and Johann Blanchard at the grand, could be successfully taken in hand. I’m sure readers will enjoy the result as much as I did.

Despite the title, the programme starts with Guilmant’s Noëls Op. 60 in solo, with Jan von Bush at the organ. These fantasies on French Christmas carols are very popular in France, but with a view to this year’s forthcoming Christmas, the choice may get extra appeal to a wider public.

New to me, and probably to many as well, the 5 Poesien, Op.35, by Karg-Elert, originally intended for harmonium and piano, flourishes in its interpretation with an organ. The harmonium part is better served, whilst the balance between the two becomes more equal. It is the romantic heart of the matter, so to speak, and it certainly does make the case for the combination.

The project wouldn’t be complete without a work of substance like Flor Peeters’ somewhat modernist Concerto for Organ and Piano, Op. 74, rendered with verve and commitment. But all things considered, my first prize goes nonetheless to Prélude, Fugue et Variation Op. 18 by César Franck. A delicate and charming arrangement of this miniature ‘evergreen’ for piano and organ, getting a well-judged performance by these two gifted artists. A personal preference which I would gladly share with others.

On the whole, however, I have no difficulty concluding: Mission accomplished! This is another interesting, worthwhile, and hardly known byway, brought to us in the typical MDG sound format.

Blangy-le-Château, Normandy, France.

Copyright © 2025 Adrian Quanjer and HRAudio.net

Performance:

Sonics (Multichannel):